
Engine on American Airlines Boeing plane blew
apart during a check nearly two weeks ago,
causing a fire and sending metal half a mile
away.
Thursday June 15, 2006
US National Transportation
Safety Board
is investigating an
uncontained engine failure
on an American Airlines 767
that occurred during a
ground maintenance test run
on June 2 at Los Angeles
International. According to
NTSB, the HPT stage one disk
on the number one GE
CF6-80A2 broke into several
pieces that "were found
embedded in the fuselage,
the number two engine, and
scattered as far 3,000 feet
from the airplane." The
ensuing holes in the wings
caused fuel leaks that
resulted in a ground fire
that was extinguished by
airport firefighters. There
were no reported injuries.
Initial examination of the
disk pieces found
indications of fatigue
cracking, the board said.
|
An explosion that ripped apart the engine of
an American Airlines jet during a ground test at
Los Angeles International Airport this month was
far more dangerous than first reported, new
details suggest.
The blast was strong enough to hurl an
18-inch chunk of metal more than half a mile --
across taxiways, service roads and two active
runways. Airport workers found the piece two
days later, not far from the airport's perimeter
fence.
The investigation into what caused the engine
to explode has focused in part on tiny cracks
found on a key piece of the turbine. An Air New
Zealand jetliner lost the same kind of engine to
similar cracks in late 2002 and was forced to
make an emergency landing.
"It was pretty fortunate that no one was
hurt," LAX spokeswoman Nancy Castles said, "and
that no planes were taking off or landing at
that time."
The Boeing 767 jet had arrived in Los Angeles
on a regular flight from New York City. Its
flight crew had reported some kind of mechanical
problem, so the airline sent the plane to
maintenance after it landed at LAX.
An airline spokesman would not discuss that
initial problem in any detail, saying only that
it was unrelated to the engine failure that
followed.
Workers were still trying to figure out what
was wrong with the airplane when they pushed the
throttle for both engines, and one of them blew
apart.
The explosion outside the American Airlines
maintenance hangar on June 2 sparked a small
fire that sent a column of dark smoke over the
passenger terminals at LAX and drew most of the
initial attention. The explosion -- officially
an "uncontained engine failure" -- gutted the
engine and blackened part of the airplane's
fuselage.
It also blasted pieces of the engine onto a
nearby runway -- and, in one case, clear across
the southern airfield. The workers who found
that piece half a mile away described it as a
wedge of metal, 2 inches thick, and heavy.
The NZ 767 Incident
The early built turbine
disks were cut by cutting
tools which then made about
10 or so turbine disks. Then
the cutting tools were
replaced and another 10 or
so turbine disks were cut
from stock.
Apparently the disks that
have been failing are the
ones that were made/cut last
before changing the cutting
tools. So now when turbine
disks are made, the cutting
tools are replaced sooner.
This apparently made for a
better quality turbine disk.
This was on the early CF6-80
A series engines.
When
the disk let go on Air NZ's
767 out of Brisbane,
Australia, the engine
stopped rotating, from climb
power, in 42 revolutions. We
counted this on the engine
casing.
The
force of this sudden stop
made the aircraft yaw so
hard that the co-pilot hit
his head against the pillar
between the windows.
There were rumors that he
was knocked out, but I'm not
sure about that one.
Boeing was glad they
strengthened up the pylon
struts coz the engine would
have fallen off the wing and
I guess the airframe would
have been lost. They knew
this because a few years
before Air NZ's incident, a
similar disk departure
happened during a
maintenance ground run where
the entire engine fell off
the wing and sat on the
ground.
Ever wondered why there is a
'dry bay' area in the wing
just above the turbine's?
It's so that an uncontained
turbine failure, should it
happen into the wing, can be
survivable.
|
Other pieces punched through the airplane's
fuselage and wings and embedded themselves in
its other engine, according to a statement
released Tuesday by the National Transportation
Safety Board. Robert Ditchey, an aviation
consultant in Marina del Rey who once oversaw
maintenance for Pan American World Airways,
called that especially worrisome.
Airline engine systems, he explained, have
extra shielding that's supposed to protect the
rest of the airplane from that kind of damage.
Pieces of the engine, he said, "are not supposed
to penetrate the fuselage" under any
circumstance.
Three maintenance workers who were on the
plane when the engine blew escaped without
injury. Nobody on the ground was hurt, either --
despite the blast of metal pieces across
taxiways and service roads usually swarming with
airport workers.
Two federal agencies are looking into the
explosion: the transportation safety board and
the Federal Aviation Administration. Both have
offices here but, in a sign of how important
this investigation is, both sent special
investigators from their Washington, D.C.,
headquarters.
Their investigations will determine whether
the flaw that destroyed the engine was an
isolated problem or could affect other airliners
still in service. "I don't think there's any
indication right now that this is a systemic
problem," FAA spokeswoman Laura Brown said.
Investigators have found evidence of "fatigue
cracking" on pieces of a disk from the engine's
turbine, the safety board said in its brief
statement.
Such cracks can develop from a microscopic
flaw in the metal and weaken engine parts
against the extraordinary stress they must
endure.
The same kind of engine, built by General
Electric, was the subject of an FAA order in
2003 that required regular inspections for
fatigue cracks. The order was prompted by the
emergency landing of the Air New Zealand plane
after one of its engines spun apart and damaged
a wing.
Such cracks are rare, Ditchey said, and
should be caught by the rigorous inspections --
"down to the last nut and bolt" -- that airlines
put their engines through. The materials used to
build an aircraft engine, he added, are "the
highest tech of the high-tech. It doesn't get
any fancier than that."
Investigators have shipped pieces of the
turbine disk shattered in the LAX explosion to
the transportation safety board's laboratory in
Washington, D.C., for further tests. The engine
itself was sent to an American Airlines
maintenance center in Oklahoma.
Airline spokesman Tim Wagner said he did not
know how long the airplane had been in service.
He said workers were conducting a routine
maintenance check known as a run-up to diagnose
an unrelated issue when the engine broke apart.
The airline, Wagner said, is "still in the
process of refurbishing the aircraft."