One day after the crash of Helios Airways Flight 522
outside Athens, Greece, aviation experts pointed to a
loss of cabin pressure as the likely cause of the
disaster that killed all 121 people aboard.
Yet all
pilots receive intense training in how to cope with such
a problem and have backup oxygen close at hand.
Consequently, the airline industry is having a hard time
figuring out how things went so terribly wrong aboard
the Cypriot 737-300.
"It's a damned odd one," said Bill Waldock, an
aviation-safety professor at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical
University in Arizona.
Waldock said the big question is why the two pilots
didn't put on their own oxygen masks and then take the
Boeing jet into a steep dive to
a safer altitude — the normal procedure to
restore proper air pressure in the cabin.
"Decompressions are not all that uncommon, but
normally the pilots are able to handle it," he said.
Lost contact at 34,000 ft.
The plane was flying at 34,000 feet when it lost
contact with air traffic controllers. If a
depressurization occurs at that altitude, most people
will lose consciousness in 15 to 60 seconds due to lack
of oxygen. Outside air temperatures hover around
minus-65 degrees Fahrenheit.
Warning horns blare inside the cockpit if there is a
problem with the pressurization system.
"They are pretty loud and annoying," said Tony
Salmon, a 737 pilot for Alaska Airlines and a spokesman
for the Air Line Pilots Association in Seattle.
"The minute you hear those warnings going off, you're
trained to grab the oxygen mask and put it on," Salmon
said.
Once their masks are on,
pilots go through a quick checklist to see if they can
regain proper pressure, Salmon said. If they can't, they
go into an emergency descent to 10,000 feet, where the
air is breathable, he said.
Salmon said pilots have access to their own oxygen
bottles, which "last a fairly long time depending on the
altitude and pressure."
In the cabin, flight attendants have portable oxygen
supplies.
Passengers get oxygen from overhead masks, which are
supplied by canisters above each half row. When
passengers pull on a string to tighten their oxygen
masks, they trigger the canisters.
Flew on autopilot
The plane that crashed, en route from the Cypriot
city of Larnaca to Athens, flew on autopilot for more
than an hour before slamming into a hillside outside
Athens.
About a half-hour into the flight, the pilots had
reported a problem with the air-conditioning system that
cools hot air produced by the engines and mixes it with
cabin air to produce the right air pressure and
temperature.
Like most modern jetliners, the 737-300 diverts
highly compressed air from its two jet engines to
maintain pressure, provide clean air for passengers and
power a variety of systems onboard.
These "bleed-air" systems take in a constant flow of
air from the engines, said Chuck Eastlake, a professor
of aerospace engineering at Embry-Riddle.
An outflow valve at the rear of the plane controls
the pressure. Open it wide, and pressure drops. Close it
down, and pressure rises.
An outflow valve stuck wide open was cited as a
possible cause of the depressurization of a Lear jet
that killed golfer Payne Stewart in 1999.
"When there is a pressurization problem the outflow
valve is always on the list of the things you look at
first," Eastlake said.
The plane's data and cockpit-voice recorders were
sent to Paris for examination, but a Greek safety
official said the voice recorder might be too damaged to
provide useful information.
Did bottled oxygen fail?
Jim Hall, former chairman of the National
Transportation Safety Board, said it was possible the
bottled oxygen in the cockpit of the Cypriot carrier
failed. The NTSB in recent years has expressed concern
about pilots' ability to get their masks on quickly
enough, Hall said.
"The accident did not have to occur," Hall said. "It
either has to be a training issue or an equipment
issue."
Eastlake also theorized that contamination or failure
of the oxygen supply could explain why the Helios pilots
did not follow normal depressurization procedures,
though he said it would be extremely unusual.
"The concept that the oxygen may have somehow been
contaminated is a very low-probability event," he said.
"But this is such a weird situation, that's definitely
something I would look at if I were investigating."
Salmon said Alaska Airlines pilots receive yearly
training on a simulator on what to do during
depressurization. He said he has never experienced
depressurization in flight.
Since 1990, there have been 172 reported incidents of
loss of cabin pressure on commercial aircraft in the
United States, according to Federal Aviation
Administration records.
No one was killed in those cases, though 28 people
were injured. Twenty of the incidents occurred on
737-300s.
1996 incident
In 1996, an incident on an American Trans Air flight
showed that minor missteps can have serious
consequences.
On that flight from Chicago to St. Petersburg, Fla.,
the cabin lost pressure at 33,000 feet with 105 people
aboard, according to FAA records.
The first officer, who was flying the Boeing 727-200,
and the flight engineer put on their oxygen masks, but
the captain waited to ask the lead flight attendant to
check whether passengers' masks had deployed.
After the flight attendant reported the masks were
working, the captain tried to put on his mask but failed
and lost consciousness, according to the FAA records.
The flight attendant also lost consciousness.
The flight engineer left his position and put a mask
on the attendant, who regained consciousness, while the
first officer put the plane into an emergency dive.
The flight attendant then put masks on the captain
and the engineer, who was now unconscious after his mask
somehow became dislodged.
After regaining consciousness, the captain landed the
plane in Indianapolis with no injuries.
After Stewart's Lear jet crash in 1999, the FAA
directed that flight manuals be rewritten to emphasize
the importance of pilots and crew putting on oxygen
masks at the first sign of depressurization.
Seattle Times staff reporter Justin Mayo and The
Associated Press contributed to this story.
David Bowermaster: 206-464-2724 or
dbowermaster@seattletimes.com Steve Miletich:
206-464-3302 or
smiletich@seattletimes.com