|
Global Travel Boom Yields
Tempting Pay for Expats;
Concerns About Safety
A Captain's New Life in Dubai
By SUSAN CAREY in Chicago, BRUCE
STANLEY in Hong Kong, AND JOHN LARKIN in Mumbai
May 5,
2006; Page A1
Nearly two years ago, at age 51, Brian Murray
took early retirement from
US Airways. The pilot was outraged by the airline's
termination of his pension plan and worried about his future
with a carrier sliding toward bankruptcy court for the second
time.
But Capt. Murray's flying career was far from
over. Today he lives in Dubai and flies wide-body Airbus A330s
for fast-growing Emirates Airlines, winging to exotic
destinations in Europe, Africa and Asia. He's home more than he
ever was at US Airways, and his total compensation package --
including health care, housing allowance, retirement plan and
vacation -- is superior. He says his wife and children enjoy
living in the United Arab Emirates, and "from a professional
standpoint, it couldn't be better."
In a new twist on global outsourcing, a flock
of U.S. pilots is fleeing the depressed North American airline
industry to work in far reaches of the world where aviation is
booming. After the 2001 terrorist attacks stifled air travel and
sent the U.S. industry into its deepest decline ever, more than
10,000 U.S. pilots were laid off, and many more took early
retirement. Despite subsequent hiring by a few healthy carriers,
including Southwest Airlines, thousands haven't been able to
find new flying jobs at their old pay grades.
At the same time, the industry is expanding
rapidly in China, India, Southeast Asia and the Middle East. As
these regions have grown more affluent and loosened aviation
restrictions, travel demand has soared. New airlines have
started up, existing carriers are adding routes, and hundreds of
new jets are on order.
So, like British and Australian pilots who long
have plied their trade wherever they find work, more Yanks are
taking their skills offshore. They are doing so despite
trepidations about moving families, flying on short-term
contracts, and sometimes giving up union rights to be called
back to work by U.S. carriers according to seniority.
U.S. pilots are working as far afield as
Bolivia, China, Qatar and Vietnam. Hong Kong-based
Cathay Pacific Airways and
Singapore Airlines are hiring more Americans, as are
carriers in Taiwan and South Korea, and increasingly, in India.
The diaspora is one symptom of a growing global
shortage of well-trained commercial pilots. Aerospace giant
Boeing Co. estimates the global jet fleet will grow to more than
35,000 airplanes in 2024, from fewer than 17,000 in 2004. Boeing
pegs demand for new pilots at nearly 18,000 a year through 2024.
China alone will need more than 35,000 new pilots over 20 years,
and the rest of Asia will need 56,500, the company estimates.
Many countries are currently unable to train enough pilots at
home.
The result: a global bazaar where experienced
pilots go to the highest bidder. Norwegians and Venezuelans are
flying in China, Egyptians and Russians in India, Jamaicans and
Iranians for a Japanese carrier. Four out of five pilots at
Qatar Airways are foreign. More than 70 Philippine Airlines
pilots have quit since 2003 for better-paying jobs elsewhere.
Etihad Airways, a new airline based in Abu Dhabi, says its No. 1
source of pilots is Malaysia. India's fleet of startup carriers
was so plagued by pilot poaching that the government last year
began requiring pilots to serve at least six months at one
carrier before moving on.
G.R. Gopinath, managing director for Air
Deccan, a two-year-old budget airline in India, says he has been
recruiting a dozen pilots a month from overseas. "If Indian
software engineers can work in the U.S., their pilots can come
and work here," he says. "It's reverse body-shopping." Pilot job
fairs in the U.S. have begun attracting recruiters for Chinese
and Indian startups, according to Kit Darby, president of Air
Inc., a placement firm.
The hiring frenzy has led to some safety
concerns. English is the industry's world-wide language. Putting
two pilots with different native languages in the same cockpit,
where they might have to interact with an air-traffic controller
whose native tongue is different still, can lead to problems,
especially in emergencies, contends Dennis Dolan, a retired
Delta Air Lines captain and president of the U.K.-based
International Federation of Air Line Pilots' Associations, which
represents pilot unions and associations in 95 countries.
The International Civil Aviation Organization,
an agency of the United Nations, intends in 2008 to begin
English-proficiency testing of pilots and air-traffic
controllers who handle international flights. India proposed
that measure after a 1996 accident in which the flight crew of a
Kazakh Airways jet misunderstood an Indian controller's
instructions, leading to a midair collision with a Saudi Arabian
Airlines plane near New Delhi. India also cited the 1995 crash
of an American Airlines jet near Cali, Colombia, in which
miscommunication between a Colombian controller and a U.S. crew
was a contributing factor.
Jim Burin, director of technical programs for
the Alexandria, Va.-based Flight Safety Foundation, an
international nonprofit group, points to another safety concern.
"In some cultures, it's not the place of the second-in-command
to question the first-in-command," he says. That could interfere
with the co-pilot's role as a check on the captain, who commands
the flight.
One pilot who moved from a U.S. airline to a
national carrier in Southeast Asia says that informational
updates on safety at his new employer arrive late or not at all,
and that little attention is paid to punctuality or how many
hours pilots work. "Training for the most part is far from the
quality I was used to in the U.S.," says the 55-year-old
captain, who asked not to be identified for fear of angering his
employer. He adds that he likes the lifestyle and finds the job
"relatively easy."
Capt. Murray, who flies out of Dubai, says
safety standards are high at Emirates, and its 1,350 pilots from
70 nations speak fluent English. He says pilots are "treated
with respect in this part of the world. We're driven to work.
We're put in four- and five-star hotels, on the concierge
floors. Captains are treated as vice presidents of the
organization."
Some out-of-work U.S. pilots balk at going
overseas for family reasons. Some hope to be recalled by U.S.
carriers and don't want to give up their seniority rights. Duane
Woerth, president of the Air Line Pilots Association, a U.S.
union, says foreign carriers are interested in senior pilots,
not junior ones. He worries about the "brain drain" and whether
foreign carriers are using U.S. pilots only temporarily until
they can staff up with their own citizens. But "our guys are
warming up to it," he says. "This one looks like a permanent
structural shift."
Andrew Baedke, who was furloughed by
Northwest Airlines after Sept. 11, has worked for the past
three years as a Honolulu-based 747 first officer, or co-pilot,
for Jalways, a subsidiary of
Japan Airlines. "A lot of my [laid-off] friends are sitting
at home or working for Home Depot," says Mr. Baedke, who is 36
years old. "I'm glad to have this job. It's extremely stable."
One reason for the pilot shortage is that
developing nations aren't training enough of them at home. There
are not enough flight schools in the world to meet demand, says
Brent Mills, the chief executive officer of Spartan College of
Aeronautics and Technology, a flight academy in Tulsa, Okla.,
that plans to open schools in India with a local partner in the
next year. It takes many years for a college graduate to
accumulate sufficient flight training and commercial flying
hours to climb the professional ladder from novice to first
officer to captain.
Some nations, such as Japan and Ethiopia, have
raised the mandatory retirement age for commercial pilots to
alleviate the shortage. ICAO, the U.N. agency, will recommend
later this year that the age be raised to 65 from 60, although
member nations will not be required to do so.
The Chinese government runs a school in Sichuan
province that graduated 307 novice pilots last year.
China Southern Airlines, the nation's largest carrier by
fleet size, has its own school in Australia. In 2004, four
Chinese investors opened Beijing PanAm International Aviation
Academy, which 240 students now attend.
Nevertheless, Gao Hongfeng, deputy director of
the Civil Aviation Administration of China, says there are
almost enough native pilots to staff the new airplanes China has
on order, but it will be difficult for the nation to train
enough "mature captains" quickly.
Chinese airlines are filling in with
expatriates. Tim Shattock, chief executive of Parc Aviation
Ltd., a Dublin firm that leases pilots to airlines, says "our
intelligence says there are 120 to 150 foreign pilots in
mainland China."
India counts more. Deregulation has spawned
startup airlines, an influx of international flights, and 20%
annual passenger growth. India expects to need 2,500 new pilots
by 2010. At Jet Airways, the nation's largest private carrier,
111 of its 685 pilots are foreign. Air Deccan has 75 foreigners
among its 250 pilots, and is setting up its own flight school in
Bangalore.
Compensation for the foreign gigs varies
widely. But it is often better than what U.S. pilots can earn at
home, where pay levels and benefits have been reduced by
bankruptcy filings and restructurings. Richard Paul, an 18-year
US Airways veteran who was bumped from captain to first officer
during one round of layoffs, says he plans to quit soon and
report for training to fly cargo at a large Asian carrier he
declines to identify. The 46-year-old pilot says he will start
as a first officer, but "in four or five years, I'll probably be
a captain on a 747 and make twice as much" as the $72,000 a year
he currently earns.
India's Air Deccan is offering $8,000 to
$15,000 a month to foreign captains, according to Mr. Gopinath,
the managing director. A captain in the U.S. on Northwest's
smallest jet earns about $9,000 a month, while a captain on
United Airlines's largest plane earns about $15,000, according
to a recent survey by Air Inc.
American Craig Harnden, formerly a pilot for
now-defunct Eastern Airlines, has worked overseas since 1990 for
Saudi Arabian Airlines, Thai Airways International and now
Singapore Airlines. "If I had known what I know now, I would
probably have left Eastern and gone overseas a lot earlier,"
says the 59-year-old Miami native, who lives in Singapore. "But
we didn't leave the airlines because of the seniority system."
William Goodwin left the U.S. in 1994 after
working for two airlines that went under and a third that was
acquired. He says he nearly doubled his pay by moving to Taiwan
to captain 767s for Taipei-based EVA Air. "It was the smartest
thing I've ever done," he says. He jumped to Korean Air in 2000,
where as a captain of 747s he earns $152,000 a year after Korean
taxes. The 54-year-old pilot says he hopes to stay until he
retires at 60.
Mr. Baedke, the former Northwest pilot who now
flies out of Honolulu for Jalways under a crew-leasing contract,
says he's trying to spread the word to other American pilots.
Many of his pilot friends, he says, were laid off after 9/11 and
have not yet been called back.
As a first officer, Mr. Baedke earns $100 an
hour, or $105,000 last year. He expects to begin training next
month to become a captain, a process he says could take 2½
years. If he succeeds, his pay will climb to $150 an hour for
the first 50 hours flown each month, and $180 an hour for
anything exceeding that.
He no longer gives much thought to returning to
Northwest. "Even if I had a chance to go back, I think I'd be at
[a regional subsidiary] as a first officer, earning $23 an
hour," he says. "There's no point."
---- Juying Qin in Hong Kong contributed to this article.
Write to
Susan Carey at
susan.carey@wsj.com
and Bruce Stanley at
bruce.stanley@wsj.com |