Civil
liberties advocates filed suit Tuesday on behalf of two
San Francisco peace activists to try to pierce the cloud
of secrecy surrounding "no-fly" lists that have snagged
thousands of air travelers nationwide.
The suit, filed in U.S. District Court in San
Francisco, seeks to require the Bush administration to
reveal how many names are on the lists, how names are
added and removed and how often they have been used to
identify the wrong person.
"Secret government lists do not allow the public to
provide any oversight or comment into our government's
activities, nor does secrecy make us any safer," said
Jayashri Srikantiah, an American Civil Liberties Union
lawyer taking part in the suit.
The ACLU said it sought the same information last
December under the Freedom of Information Act, but the
FBI replied that it had no such documents, and the
Transportation Security Administration never replied.
Another question posed by the suit was whether the
government is targeting political activists like Rebecca
Gordon and Jan Adams.
The two women, who help publish the anti-war
newspaper War Times, were detained briefly at San
Francisco International Airport last August after their
names showed up on a no-fly list at the American Trans
Air counter. They were allowed to board their flight to
Boston when officers didn't find their names on an "FBI
list," according to police reports, but their bags were
subjected to additional searches.
"Does someone in some government agency believe that
our opposition to the current war policy means we are
likely to commit terrorist acts?" Gordon and Adams
asked. About 20 activists in Milwaukee asked similar
questions a year ago after they were stopped at an
airline terminal and missed their flight to a political
gathering in Washington, D.C.
The government has provided little information about
the data it has supplied to airlines since the Sept. 11,
2001, terrorist attacks.
But Heather Rosenker, spokeswoman for the
Transportation Security Administration, denied Tuesday
that anyone was on the government "watch lists" because
of political affiliation or beliefs.
"The objective is to find terrorists and people
affiliated with terrorists, " Rosenker said.
She acknowledged technical problems with computer
links between airline databases and two lists compiled
by her agency: the "no-fly" list of suspected terrorists
and a list of "selectees," deemed less of a threat, who
are subjected to added searches of their persons or
luggage.
Evidence of those technical problems was provided by
the ACLU, which released a summary from SFO of 339
people stopped at the airport between September 2001 and
last month because they showed up on an airline's list.
Police were summoned in virtually every case, but all
but a handful were listed as cleared or dropped. It
wasn't clear from the report what the outcome was in
those few cases.
Adams, War Times' national distribution manager and
co-publisher, said she had learned she had been detained
and questioned because the actual no-fly list includes a
J. Adams. Numerous similar incidents have been reported
elsewhere.
To help resolve passenger civil rights and privacy
complaints, the TSA recently hired its first ombudsman,
Kim Walton. People can send complaint letters to Office
of Ombudsman, Transportation Security Administration,
701 S. 12th St., 2nd Floor, Arlington, VA 22202.